Beyond Academics: How Safety Ensures Mission-Aligned Student Retention

BY SUSAN LAIR, PHD - CONSULTANT, EXECUTIVE COACH

When parents choose a private school for their children, safety is often one of their top three priorities. Beyond academic excellence, extracurricular opportunities, and strong values, parents want to know that their child is protected, both physically and emotionally. In today’s world, ensuring a safe learning environment is not only a moral obligation but also a critical factor in retaining mission-aligned students and families. Schools that prioritize safety demonstrate their commitment to student well-being, fostering trust and long-term loyalty from families who share their educational philosophy.

However, it is not enough for school administrators to simply say they prioritize safety—they must actively demonstrate it. Schools must have clear, actionable policies in place to prevent and address threats to student welfare. Schools must ensure that every classroom is a place of respect, encouragement, and intellectual curiosity. Teachers play a critical role in shaping a student’s confidence, and no child should ever feel intimidated or belittled for asking a question or seeking help. Heads of School and leadership teams must set clear expectations that all educators foster a supportive learning environment—one where mistakes are seen as opportunities for growth, and students feel safe to engage, take risks, and develop a love of learning.

Close supervision, rigorous background checks, ongoing staff training, and transparent reporting structures are essential components of a comprehensive safety strategy. Additionally, facility design plays a crucial role in ensuring student protection. Schools should implement physical safety measures such as windows in classroom doors, surveillance cameras in appropriate locations, and secure campus access points to enhance visibility and accountability. Parents and students deserve more than reassurance; they need to see that the school’s leadership means what they say and follow through with meaningful protections that create a truly secure and nurturing environment. Ensuring a safe learning environment is not just a moral obligation but a non-negotiable expectation.

The Intersection of Safety and Mission Alignment

Mission-aligned students and families seek an environment that reflects their values. For many, this includes a school culture that nurtures not only intellectual growth but also emotional security and moral development. If safety is compromised, it threatens the very foundation of this trust, leading families to reconsider their choice of school. A well-executed safety strategy assures parents that their values—and their children—are well protected.

Key Components of a Safe School Environment

1. Physical Security Measures

A secure campus is fundamental to a school’s ability to retain students. Schools must implement:

• Gated entry points and controlled access to facilities.

• Security cameras and on-site personnel to monitor activity.

• Strict visitor check-in procedures with ID verification.

• Windows in classroom doors

• Glass music practice rooms, tutorial rooms, athletic training rooms and other one-on-one environments

• Well-lit and properly maintained facilities that discourage security breaches.

In lieu of turning your school into a fortress, which still provides no guarantee, a school’s Board and Head of School must determine the right security balance. When security measures are visible and well-communicated, parents feel reassured that their children are in a secure learning space.

2. Emergency Preparedness and Crisis Management

A proactive approach to emergency preparedness is vital. Schools must develop and regularly update emergency response plans, including:

• Lockdown, fire, and weather drills conducted consistently.

• Staff, parents and students trained in first aid, CPR, and active threat responses.

• Clear communication channels for immediate alerts to parents and authorities.

Parents appreciate knowing that their child’s school is not only prepared for emergencies but also capable of handling crises effectively.

3. Emotional and Psychological Safety

Beyond physical safety, emotional well-being is essential for a productive learning environment. Schools must foster:

• A culture of respect and kindness to prevent bullying and social isolation along with policies and procedures for discipline up to removal of individuals that threaten a culture of respect and kindness.  

• Access to counselors and mental health resources for students.

• Faculty and staff training to recognize signs of emotional distress and provide support.

• Protocols and procedures consistently implemented for students and families experiencing loss and grief

When students feel emotionally safe, they are more likely to stay engaged and thrive academically, reinforcing the school’s mission and the family’s commitment to the school.

4. Health and Wellness Standards

A school’s commitment to student health further strengthens its reputation as a safe haven. Schools should implement:

• Rigorous cleanliness and sanitation practices.

• Clear illness prevention protocols, including vaccination and hygiene education.

• Clear and consistently implemented best practice responses to student injury

• Nutritional and student friendly meal plans that cater to allergies and dietary restrictions.

Parents want assurance that their children’s health is a top priority, influencing their decision to remain at the school long-term.

5. Digital Safety and Cybersecurity

With increasing technology integration in education, digital safety is a growing concern. Schools should:

• Educate students on responsible internet usage and online privacy.

• Monitor school-provided devices and networks 24/7 for potential threats.

• Offer parental guidance and age-appropriate training on maintaining digital safety at home.

By taking an active role in cybersecurity, schools further reinforce their commitment to comprehensive safety.

6. Comprehensive Employee Training

Ensuring student safety starts with equipping educators and staff with the knowledge, awareness, and vigilance needed to protect children. Schools must go beyond standard hiring practices to implement ongoing, proactive training that reinforces a culture of safety and accountability. Key components include:

• Thorough Background Checks: Conduct extensive background screenings during hiring and implement periodic random checks throughout employment.

• Life-Saving Training: Require Red Cross First Aid, CPR, and Shaken Baby Syndrome training at least every two years.

• Child Protection Awareness: Review Child Protective Services (CPS) rules and regulations with faculty and staff at the start of each school year.

• Recognizing Predators: Provide regular, in-depth training on identifying and preventing grooming behaviors and potential abuse.

• Clear Enforceable Safety Policies: Establish and consistently uphold policies that address critical areas, including: 

• Student transportation, including seatbelt requirements and guidelines for students riding or not riding with with parents, coaches, or teachers.

• Social media boundaries for students, parents, and teachers.

• Cyber harassment and online safety measures.

• Prevention and response protocols for harassment, sexual misconduct, and inappropriate relationships.

• Ensuring classrooms remain free from external social or political agendas.

• Creating an environment where students feel safe, valued, and free to be their authentic selves.

• Knowledge of Local, State and Federal Guidelines and Laws: 

By prioritizing rigorous and continuous teacher training, schools reinforce their unwavering commitment to student safety—because a well-trained faculty is the frontline defense against potential threats.

7. Retaining Students Requires Clear and Timely Communication with Parents

In times of crisis, uncertainty fuels fear. Parents need to know that their children are safe, and schools must have a well-structured plan for communicating emergencies and safety breaches. Clear, timely, and transparent communication is not just about information, it’s about trust.

• Proactive Communication Plans
  Parents should not have to wonder how they will receive information in an emergency. Schools should regularly communicate their emergency protocols, conduct drills, and ensure families are aware of the channels through which they will be contacted.

• Emergency Notification Systems
  Schools should implement reliable, multi-channel notification systems, such as text alerts, emails, app notifications, and automated calls. These tools provide real-time updates, ensuring parents receive accurate information as quickly as possible.

• Balancing Transparency and Privacy
  While transparency is key, schools must also be mindful of privacy laws and student confidentiality. Sharing enough information to keep parents informed without violating privacy regulations is a careful balancing act that requires thoughtful planning.

• Post-Incident Follow-Ups
  After an emergency, communication should not stop. Providing follow-up messages with clear next steps, resources for student well-being, and opportunities for parent questions reassures families. Rather than increasing doubt it reinforces confidence in the school’s leadership.

When parents trust that their child’s safety is a priority and that they will be kept informed, they are more likely to remain committed to the school community. Retaining students starts with making parents feel secure in their decision to entrust their child’s well-being to the school.

How Safety Drives Retention

A well-implemented safety strategy is more than a policy—it’s a testament to a school’s dedication to its students and mission. When parents see that safety is prioritized, they feel confident in their choice, reducing attrition rates. Families who trust that their children are secure are more likely to remain engaged in the school community, contribute to its success, and advocate for its growth.

Moreover, safety is a powerful marketing tool. Word-of-mouth recommendations from satisfied families who feel their children are protected can drive new enrollments, further strengthening the school’s mission-aligned student body.

School Safety Is Not Optional: It’s a Key Component of Student Retention

A safe school is a thriving school. Safety should not be just an accreditation checkbox or a policy. Ensuring physical security, emotional well-being, health standards, and digital protection is not just about accreditation compliance, it’s about fostering an environment where students can learn, grow, and succeed without fear. It is the key to mission alignment, student retention, and the sustainability of your school.

As Heads of School, we must ensure that every policy, every training session, and every safety measure is implemented with unwavering commitment and consistency. The future of education depends on schools where students feel protected, respected, and free to learn.

The time to prepare is now. Schools that neglect safety risk losing the trust of families—and, more importantly, the mission-aligned students you are entrusted to protect. As Heads of School, prioritizing safety and mental well-being alongside academic excellence is not just a responsibility, it’s a commitment to the future. Take a hard look at how your school safeguards its students, because nothing is more important than their well-being.

---

RESOURCES

Hotchkiss School: https://www.hotchkiss.org/top-benefits-of-private-school

Fraser Institute, Studies in Educational Policy, Private Schools, who chooses them and why. Deani A. Van Pelt, Patricia A. Allison, and Derek J. Allison

Enrollment Management Association, EMA, https://www.admission.org/

Readiness and Emergency Management for Schools. Addressing and Preventing Adult Sexual Misconduct.  info@remstacenter.org | https://rems.ed.gov/ | @remstacenter

FEMA. National Incident Mangement 

Raptor Technologies. School Pass. Top Safety Strategies Used by Private Schools: https://schoolpass.com/top-safety-strategies-used-by-private-schools

US News and World Report. What Parents Need to Know about Private School Safety: https://www.usnews.com/education/k12/articles/what-parents-need-to-know-about-private-school-safety-plans

McMillian Pazdan Smith Architecture: https://www.mcmillanpazdansmith.com/k-12-blog/safety-and-security-in-private-schools/

Best Program -- Harvard Westlake School has a great Health and Wellness page on their website that provides their Mental Health and Wellness Plan, contact information for school counselors, resources and websites: https://www.hw.com/life-at-hw/Health-Wellness

Phillips Academy Andover has a great Support and Safety program: https://www.andover.edu/living/health-and-wellness

The Brearley School in New York has an excellent multi-prong student health and safety program: https://www.brearley.org/counseling-health-services/

https://www.brearley.org/news/good-decisions-last-for-generations/

St. John’s in Houston Texas has a speaker series - Justise Winslow '14 - "Best Version of Me": https://www.sjs.org/news-detail?pk=1036225

The Lawrenceville School New Jersey has a nice health and wellness program with a huge staff: https://www.lawrenceville.org/life-at-lawrenceville/student-life/health-wellness

The Regis School New York City Protecting Our Students: https://www.regis.org/protecting-our-students/

Flintridge Preparatory School California: https://www.flintridgeprep.org/student-life/student-support-well-being